Eurax vs Natural Itch Cream – Which Is Right for You?

Eurax vs Natural Itch Cream – Which Is Right for You?

If you’ve ever stood in a chemist’s aisle scratching your head (and maybe your arms too), wondering whether Eurax Cream is your best option for itchy skin — you’re not alone.

Eurax is one of the most well-known medicated creams for itching in the UK. But more and more people are turning to natural itch relief alternatives – and with good reason.

Let’s break it down.

🔬 What Is Eurax Cream?

Eurax contains Crotamiton, an anti-parasitic and anti-itch ingredient. It’s typically used for conditions like:

  • Eczema

  • Scabies

  • Allergic skin rashes

  • Insect bites

✅ Pros:

  • Medically approved for pruritus (itching)

  • Fast-acting for severe itch

  • Available over the counter

❌ Cons:

  • Contains synthetic ingredients

  • Not ideal for long-term use

  • Can cause dryness or stinging in sensitive skin

🌿 What About Natural Itch Creams?

Natural creams avoid synthetic chemicals and use plant-based ingredients to hydrate, soothe and protect the skin barrier. Think:

  • Calendula

  • Beeswax

  • Essential oils (e.g. lavender, thyme)

  • Vitamin E

  • Natural carrier oils like sunflower or almond

These are commonly used in handmade products like Herbalshire’s Handmade Itch Relief Salve

✅ Pros:

  • Gentle on sensitive or allergy-prone skin

  • No steroids or synthetic preservatives

  • Safe for daily use

  • Vegan & cruelty-free

  • Often handmade in small batches

❌ Cons:

  • Slower-acting than medicated creams for acute flare-ups

  • Not suitable for infections or severe skin conditions (see GP)

⚖️ Quick Comparison Table

Feature Eurax Cream Natural Itch Cream (Herbalshire)
Active Ingredient Crotamiton (synthetic) Plant-based oils & extracts
Suitable for Daily Use ✖ ✔
Works on Eczema & Dry Skin ✔ (short term) ✔ (long term)
Safe for Sensitive Skin ✖ Sometimes causes sting ✔ Gentle & soothing
Cruelty-Free / Vegan ✖ ✔
Made in the UK ✔ (pharma lab) ✔ (handmade in Yorkshire)

🛍️ Which One Is Right for You?

👉 Choose Eurax if:

  • You need fast relief from intense itching (e.g. scabies or allergic rash)

  • You don’t mind synthetic ingredients for short-term use

👉 Choose a Natural Cream if:

  • You want a gentle solution for dry, itchy skin

  • You prefer handmade, plant-based skincare

  • You need something safe for daily, long-term use

💡 Looking for a safe, effective Eurax cream alternative?
Try our Herbalshire Handmade Itch Relief Salve – trusted by customers across the UK for natural skin soothing.

Back to blog